Documentaries that changed the rules
Seven films that each changed what a documentary was allowed to do, in order of date from 1933 to 2012. They were filmed in Spain, France, Iran, Argentina, Japan and Indonesia.
Who decides what is true here, the filmmaker or the people being filmed?
Land Without Bread
Luis Buñuel, 1933
Half an hour in Las Hurdes, a poor mountain district of Spain. A detached voice describes hunger and death while Brahms's Fourth Symphony plays. Parts were staged, and the crew shot the goat that falls from the cliff. Ask how far you trust the narrator.
Chronicle of a Summer
Jean Rouch and Edgar Morin, 1961
Paris, summer 1960. An anthropologist and a sociologist ask people about happiness and work, using a new light camera that records sound as it films. At the end the participants watch the footage and argue about how true it is. The term cinéma vérité was coined for this film.
The House Is Black
Forough Farrokhzad, 1963
The only film by the poet Forough Farrokhzad, twenty minutes inside the Bababaghi leper colony in Iran. Over scenes of school, meals and board games she reads from the Old Testament, the Qur'an and her own poems. Afterwards she adopted a boy from the colony. Keep looking at the faces.
The Hour of the Furnaces
Octavio Getino and Fernando Solanas, 1968
Four hours in three parts, made in Argentina between 1966 and 1968 under military rule and shown in secret at clubs and meetings. It was divided so that the audience could stop and argue after each section. Start with part one, and watch how the cattle auction is cut.
The Emperor's Naked Army Marches On
Kazuo Hara, 1987
Kenzo Okuzaki, a veteran of Japan's war in New Guinea, goes from door to door to make old comrades say why two soldiers were shot after the war had ended. He shouts at them and sometimes hits them. Hara followed him for five years. Decide when the camera should have stopped.
The Gleaners and I
Agnès Varda, 2000
Varda travels round France with a small digital camera, her first, meeting people who live on what others leave, from misshapen potatoes in the fields to food in restaurant bins. She counts her own filming as gleaning too. Look for the heart-shaped potatoes and the dance of the lens cap.
The Act of Killing
Joshua Oppenheimer, 2012
In Medan, Indonesia, men who killed alleged communists in 1965 and 1966 were never punished. Oppenheimer asks them to act out what they did as scenes from a gangster film, a western and a musical, and they agree gladly. Watch Anwar Congo's face as the filming goes on.