Good criticism

Essays5 steps

Five pieces by critics and reporters at their best. Each shows a way of paying attention that you can borrow.

What did the writer see that you had missed?

The Decay of Cinema

Susan Sontag, 1996 · 8 min

Written for the hundredth birthday of film. Sontag says that what has died is cinephilia, the particular love people once had for films. Eight minutes, and still argued over.

Great Movie: Tokyo Story

Roger Ebert, 2003 · 7 min

Ebert writes about Ozu in plain sentences and explains what the still camera is doing without any jargon. Read it straight after you see the film.

Il Maestro

Martin Scorsese, 2021 · 22 min

Scorsese remembers New York in the years when a new Fellini film was an event. Around that memory he builds an argument about what is lost when films are treated as content.

Listen to This

Alex Ross, 2004 · 35 min

Ross, the New Yorker's music critic, says he hates the term classical music because it shuts living work inside a museum. He describes hearing Beethoven and Bob Dylan with the same ears.

Frank Sinatra Has a Cold

Gay Talese, 1966 · 65 min

Esquire sent Talese to interview Sinatra, who refused. Talese spent weeks watching him and talking to the people around him instead. The result is taught in journalism schools.

All paths