Arguments you may resist
Five well-made arguments for positions you may not hold. You do not have to agree. Notice the point where you start to object.
Which of these did you resist, and what was the resistance protecting?
A Defence of Penny Dreadfuls
G. K. Chesterton, 1901 · 10 min
Chesterton defends the cheap adventure papers that respectable people blamed for corrupting boys. He thinks the fault lies with the critics. A short lesson in how not to sneer.
Good Bad Books
George Orwell, 1945 · 7 min
Orwell on novels with no literary standing that people go on reading for decades, such as Sherlock Holmes. He asks what they have that better books lack. Seven minutes.
Beauty and Desecration
Roger Scruton, 2009 · 20 min
A conservative philosopher argues that much modern art set out to spoil beauty and that we are poorer for it. You may disagree with most of it. Read it to find out exactly where.
I Can Tolerate Anything Except the Outgroup
Scott Alexander, 2014 · 40 min
Scott Alexander asks why people who are proud of their tolerance still despise one group, usually the one closest to home. It is long, and uncomfortable from either political side.
Famine, Affluence, and Morality
Peter Singer, 1972 · 30 min
If you would wade into a pond and ruin your clothes to save a child, Singer asks, why not give the same amount to save one far away? The argument takes a page and is hard to answer.